Diamondbacks open to adding full-time designated hitter

The annual Winter Meetings are taking place in Nashville this week and Steve Gilbert of MLB.com was able to discuss the ongoing offseason with Diamondbacks general manager Mike Hazen.

The club is in a very different position than some other recent years. They missed the playoffs in five straight years from 2018 to 2022, including an especially rough 110-loss season in 2021, but were able to go all the way to the World Series in 2023. Though they ultimately lost to the Rangers, the momentum from that run and the extra revenue from those playoff games could perhaps lead to a different offseason approach this winter.

“We’re engaged in the market more aggressively,” Hazen said. “It’s not to say that something’s going to happen involving us there, but I think we’re probably in a little different spot than we have been in the past going into the Winter Meetings is how I would characterize it.” 

Hazen goes on to suggest they are unlikely to made a trade involving someone currently on their major league roster, meaning they are likely looking to free agency or perhaps trades of prospects.

One thing that is definitely on the wish list is another right-handed bat. The club already brought one aboard by trading for Eugenio Suárez a couple of weeks ago, but that still leaves them a bit behind last year’s team. Each of Lourdes Gurriel Jr., Tommy Pham and Evan Longoria reached free agency at season’s end, subtracting three righty bats from the mix. The club could acquire a right-handed hitting outfielder, though Hazen says they are also open to bringing in a full-time designated hitter.

“I think a right-handed bat is [a need],” Hazen said. “I wouldn’t say a right-handed-hitting outfielder. A right-handed bat is somebody that would help fill out our lineup. There are options and various places to get that. Depending on who that was, where that landed, how that fit, I think we would have more flexibility for how the rest of it would come together.” 

The outfield market has some options for a right-handed bat, including re-signing Pham or Gurriel. Then there’s also Teoscar Hernández, Harrison Bader, Adam Duvall and others. But by being open to a player that would be limited to DH duties would give them some more options.

J.D. Martinez is coming off a strong 33-homer season but needs a DH slot, having played just 12 innings in the outfield this year and none at all in 2022. Jorge Soler had 36 home runs in 2023 and should be capable of a bit more work in the field than Martinez, with 32 games in right field in 2023. However, he’s generally considered a poor fielder and fits best on a club with an open DH spot.

 Justin Turner can play the infield corners, and even second base in a pinch, but is now 39 and best suited for a part-time defensive role. Catcher Mitch Garver has a potent bat but has seen injuries diminish his ability to squat behind the plate with regularity. First baseman Rhys Hoskins missed all of 2023 due to a torn ACL and should perhaps be signed by a club that can use the DH spot to give him a lighter workload next year. The club was speculatively connected to Martinez on the weekend and has had previous reported interest in Turner. On the trade market, Eloy Jiménez, Randy Arozarena, Tyler O’Neill, Nick Castellanos or Christopher Morel could perhaps fit the needs in Arizona.

That gives the D’Backs plenty of options to consider, none of whom should be strictly off the table financially, even though the club hasn’t been a huge spender. Roster Resource currently estimates next year’s payroll to be at $114M right now. They have been as high as $132M in the past, per the data at Cot’s Baseball Contracts. If their recent World Series run allows them to get back into that range or a bit beyond, then they have some money to work with. But the club needs to add some pitching and will have to balance those needs as the offseason continues to develop.